May 16, 2023

To Paint or Replace Your Garage Door: A Comparative Analysis with Canadoor

The garage door, a prominent feature of your home’s facade, is not just an entryway but also contributes significantly to your property’s curb appeal. Over time, exposure to weather and natural wear can deteriorate its appearance and functionality, leaving homeowners with a decision to make – rejuvenate the old door with a fresh coat of paint or opt for a brand-new replacement.

While painting could be a tempting choice, it’s worth noting that Canadoor does not offer painting services but excels in garage door replacement, providing new doors with a lifetime paint warranty. Here’s a thorough comparison to help you weigh your options.

Painting Your Existing Garage Door

Pros of Painting:

  • Cost-Effective: Generally, painting a garage door is less costly than replacing it. The expenses primarily include paint and potentially hiring a professional painter.
  • Aesthetic Flexibility: Painting provides the opportunity to change the garage door’s colour and finish, allowing you to align it with your home’s exterior design or your personal aesthetic.
  • Environmental Responsibility: By reusing your current garage door, you reduce waste and material consumption, making painting a more eco-friendly option.

Cons of Painting:

  • Time-Consuming: The painting process can be lengthy, particularly if the door requires substantial prep work such as sanding, priming, and multiple paint coats.
  • Short-Term Fix: While painting can transform the door’s appearance, it does not address any structural or insulation issues or outdated operating mechanisms.
  • Maintenance: Painted doors might require more frequent touch-ups due to exposure to harsh weather or direct sunlight.

Replacing Your Garage Door with Canadoor

Pros of Replacing:

  • Enhanced Functionality: A new garage door from Canadoor promises improved functionality, smoother and quieter operation, and potentially modern features like smart home compatibility.
  • Superior Energy Efficiency: Canadoor’s garage doors come with superior insulation, promoting energy efficiency by maintaining consistent temperatures within the garage.
  • Boosted Home Value: According to the Remodeling Magazine’s Cost vs. Value Report, garage door replacement is a top home improvement project for return on investment. A new garage door can significantly elevate your home’s curb appeal and resale value.
  • Lifetime Paint Warranty: A standout benefit of Canadoor’s garage doors is their lifetime paint warranty, eliminating the concern for paint maintenance or potential fading.

Cons of Replacing:

  • Cost: Replacing a garage door involves a larger upfront cost, encompassing the price of the door, its installation, and associated hardware.
  • Installation Time: Removing the old door and installing a new one can be disruptive and may take longer than a simple paint job.
  • Environmental Consideration: Although replacing your garage door implies that the old one could end up in a landfill, Canadoor ensures that old doors are disposed of responsibly or recycled where possible.


Your choice between painting and replacing your garage door hinges on your specific needs and situation. If your garage door is still structurally sound and you’re primarily interested in an aesthetic upgrade, painting might be your solution. But if your door is aging, lacks efficiency, or has significant structural issues, replacing it with a new one from Canadoor – complete with a lifetime paint warranty – could be the smartest long-term investment. Always consider factors such as cost, time, functionality, and environmental impact to make an informed decision.