August 3, 2023

Rolling Steel Overhead Door vs. Sectional Overhead Door: Which is Better?

Determining the best fit for your garage requires a deeper understanding of the various options available. In this riveting comparison article, we’re rolling up our sleeves to delve into the advantages and differences between two popular contenders: Rolling Steel Overhead Doors and Sectional Overhead Doors. With their unique features and functions, each has its own merit. But when it comes down to choosing between them, which one proves to be superior? Saddle up as we embark on this comparative journey, making your decision-making easier and more informed. Your ideal garage door might just be a scroll away!

A rolling steel overhead door is made of interlocking slats that roll up and store above the opening, while a sectional overhead door consists of several panels that are hinged together and slide up and overhead, parallel with the ceiling. Rolling steel doors are generally more durable and require less maintenance but can be more expensive upfront compared to sectional doors which take up less ceiling space. However, sectional doors can be insulated more effectively and offer more design options, coupled with ease of use in most situations. The best option depends on your specific needs and budget constraints. Consult with our experts at Local Garage Door Service to help you determine which type of overhead door is right for your needs.

Analysing Overhead Door Types

When it comes to choosing the right overhead door for your commercial or industrial space, it’s important to consider the different types available and their unique characteristics. The two main options that often come up in this discussion are rolling steel overhead doors and sectional overhead doors. Let’s analyse these two types to understand their features and determine which one might be better suited for your specific needs.

  • As per a survey conducted by Door + Access Systems Manufacturers Association (DASMA), in terms of overall sales, sectional doors have an edge over rolling steel doors with them accounting approximately for 56% of the total commercial sales in 2019.
  • In another report by Grand View Research Inc., the durability of rolling steel doors is highlighted as they can last up to 30 years or more if well maintained, while sectional doors typically have a lifespan ranging from 15 to 20 years.
  • According to Resolution Engineering & Deploying, energy efficiency comparisons showed that insulated rolling steel doors have a better thermal performance rating (U-Factor as low as 0.29) than commercial sectional overhead doors (U-Factor cannot realistically be less than about 0.40). This suggests that rolling steel doors can offer more significant energy savings.

Rolling Steel Overhead Door Characteristics

Rolling steel overhead doors are renowned for their durability, strength, and security. These doors are constructed from interlocking slats made of steel or aluminium. When the door is opened, the slats roll up into a coil above the opening, saving valuable space inside the building. This design also ensures smooth operation with minimal noise.

Imagine you have a warehouse with limited space or need to maximise tight areas within your commercial property. A rolling steel overhead door can be an excellent choice due to its compact design when opened.

The robust construction of rolling steel doors makes them ideal for high-traffic areas or environments where security is a top priority. They provide excellent protection against forced entry attempts and can withstand heavy impact, making them suitable for applications such as warehouses, distribution centres, parking garages, or manufacturing facilities.

Another advantage of rolling steel overhead doors is their versatility. They can be customised to fit various architectural styles, come in different colours, and offer options for insulation and advanced safety features.

However, there are a few considerations to keep in mind if you’re considering a rolling steel overhead door. The installation process may require more time and expertise due to the complexity of assembling and balancing the individual slats. Additionally, in case of damage or wear to a single slat, it may be necessary to replace the entire coil assembly rather than just the affected area.

Now that we’ve explored the characteristics of rolling steel overhead doors, let’s move on to discussing the features of sectional overhead doors.

Sectional Overhead Door Features

Sectional overhead doors have become a popular choice for both residential and commercial properties due to their exceptional features. Let’s explore some of the key characteristics that make sectional overhead doors stand out:

  1. Versatility: Sectional overhead doors are available in various materials, including steel, wood, and aluminium, allowing homeowners and business owners to choose a style that matches their aesthetic preferences. This versatility enables customization and ensures that the door seamlessly blends with the overall design of the property.
  2. Insulation: Many sectional overhead doors feature insulation options, making them an excellent choice for properties located in extreme climates. The insulation helps regulate indoor temperatures and can contribute to energy efficiency by reducing heat loss or gain through the garage.
  3. Space-saving: Sectional overhead doors are designed to maximise space utilisation. Instead of swinging outwards like traditional hinged doors, sectional doors open vertically along tracks, which allows for more usable space inside and outside the garage. This vertical opening mechanism is particularly beneficial for properties with limited driveway or ceiling clearance.
  4. Safety features: Sectional overhead doors prioritise safety by incorporating advanced safety features. These may include photoelectric sensors that detect obstacles in the door’s path and automatically reverse its direction to prevent accidents or damage. Additionally, tamper-resistant bottom brackets help secure the door against forced entry attempts.
  5. Noise reduction: With noise being a common concern, especially for properties close to busy streets or located near living spaces, sectional overhead doors often come equipped with noise-reducing features such as nylon rollers and vibration isolation systems. These elements minimise operational noise, allowing for quieter door movements.
  6. Security: Sectional overhead doors offer enhanced security measures compared to traditional doors. Reinforced panels made from durable materials provide increased resistance against attempted break-ins. Additionally, many models incorporate locking systems to further enhance security.

All these features combined make sectional overhead doors a reliable and practical choice for both residential and commercial properties. They offer convenience, durability, and aesthetic appeal along with added safety and security features.

Think of a sectional overhead door as a versatile superhero, working diligently to provide insulation, space-saving benefits, enhanced safety, reduced noise levels, and superior security – all while looking stylish and elegant.

Now that we have explored the noteworthy features of sectional overhead doors, let’s compare them to rolling steel doors in terms of construction and design.

Construction and Design Comparative Overview

When it comes to comparing the construction and design of sectional overhead doors and rolling steel doors, there are notable differences worth considering:

  1. Door Structure: Sectional overhead doors consist of individual horizontal panels hinged together, which allows them to open vertically along tracks. In contrast, rolling steel doors comprise interconnected slats that coil overhead when the door is opened. This difference in structure affects the installation process and overall design aesthetics.
  2. Application Suitability: While sectional overhead doors are versatile and suitable for various applications ranging from residential garages to commercial warehouses, rolling steel doors excel in industrial settings where durability and strength are paramount. They can withstand heavy usage in challenging environments like manufacturing facilities or distribution centres.
  3. Space Requirements: Sectional overhead doors require adequate headroom above the opening for the door tracks and hardware to be installed. On the other hand, rolling steel doors roll up tightly into a compact coil above the opening. This space-saving feature makes rolling steel doors ideal for situations where headroom is limited.
  4. Durability: Rolling steel doors are constructed using sturdy materials such as galvanised steel or aluminium with reinforced slats, making them highly durable and capable of withstanding harsh conditions. They are designed to withstand impact, provide resistance against unauthorised entry attempts, and offer excellent protection against weather elements.
  5. Customization: Sectional overhead doors typically provide a broader range of customization options in terms of materials, finishes, and designs. Rolling steel doors focus more on functionality and strength, with fewer design options available.

Considering these factors, it becomes clear that the choice between sectional overhead doors and rolling steel doors depends on the specific requirements and preferences of the property owner or manager. The decision is influenced by factors such as application suitability, available space, desired level of durability, and aesthetic considerations.

  • When choosing between sectional overhead doors and rolling steel doors, it’s important to consider factors such as door structure, application suitability, space requirements, durability, and customization options. While sectional overhead doors are versatile and can be used in various applications, rolling steel doors excel in industrial settings where strength and durability are key. Rolling steel doors also take up less space due to their compact coil design. Owners should consider their specific requirements and preferences when deciding between these two types of doors.

Cost and Maintenance: Rolling Steel vs. Sectional

When it comes to choosing between a rolling steel overhead door and a sectional overhead door, the cost and maintenance aspects play a crucial role in the decision-making process.

Cost: The initial cost of installation can vary between rolling steel and sectional doors. Generally, sectional doors tend to be more affordable upfront due to their design and construction. They are typically made of individual panels that are connected. On the other hand, rolling steel doors consist of a single curtain that rolls up and down, which makes them more complex and often pricier to instal. However, it’s important to consider long-term costs as well.

Let’s say you operate a busy warehouse with constant traffic in and out. In this case, the durability of rolling steel doors might save you money in the long run since they are built to withstand heavy usage and potential impacts. Sectional doors may require more frequent repairs or panel replacements, especially if exposed to high traffic or harsh weather conditions.

Maintenance: Both types of doors require regular maintenance to ensure smooth operation and prolong their lifespan. However, the specific maintenance needs can differ for rolling steel and sectional doors.

Rolling steel doors typically have fewer moving parts compared to sectional doors, which can make them easier to maintain. Simple maintenance tasks like lubricating tracks and inspecting springs can generally keep rolling steel doors in good working condition.

On the other hand, sectional doors consist of multiple sections and hinges, which may require occasional adjustments or replacements. The panels themselves can also be susceptible to dents or damage over time from accidental impacts.

It’s essential to consider both upfront cost and long-term maintenance requirements when making your decision. Assessing factors such as the expected usage, level of security needed, and environmental conditions will help determine which option offers a better return on investment for your specific situation.

With an understanding of cost and maintenance, let’s now delve into another significant aspect to consider: comparing the automated features of rolling steel and sectional doors.

Comparing Automated Features

Automated features are a major consideration for many businesses when choosing between rolling steel overhead doors and sectional overhead doors. Let’s explore the convenience and ease of use provided by both options.

Convenience: Both rolling steel and sectional doors can be equipped with automation systems, allowing for effortless operation. However, there are a few differences worth considering.

Rolling steel doors typically have a compact design that allows for minimal space utilisation. They can be easily integrated with advanced control systems, enabling seamless integration with security systems, access control, and other automation technologies. This provides a high level of convenience in managing entrances and exits efficiently.

Sectional doors, while often more straightforward in terms of their operation, may require additional space due to the individual panel design. However, modern sectional door systems also offer convenient automated features such as remote control access or smartphone connectivity.

Ease of Use: Both types of doors can offer smooth and user-friendly automation features when installed correctly. However, it’s important to consider the reliability and functionality of the automated systems accompanying each type.

Rolling steel doors are known for their robust construction, which provides durability even in demanding industrial settings. The automated features designed specifically for rolling steel doors are engineered to withstand heavy usage without compromising performance or safety.

Sectional doors typically come with reliable automation systems that allow for easy opening and closing. These systems often include safety mechanisms such as sensors or detection features to prevent accidents or damage during operation.

When considering the convenience and ease of use provided by automated features, it’s essential to assess your specific needs in terms of security, traffic flow, and integration with other building systems. Consulting with an experienced garage door professional can help you determine which option is best suited for your business’s requirements.

Convenience and Ease of Use

When comparing rolling steel overhead doors to sectional overhead doors, one crucial factor to consider is the convenience and ease of use. Both types of doors have their own unique features that impact how easily they can be operated.

Rolling steel overhead doors are known for their compact design and vertical operation. These doors consist of interlocking slats that roll up into a coil above the door opening, allowing for maximum use of the available space. This design makes them an excellent option in situations where headroom is limited or when you need to maximise the available ceiling space in your garage or warehouse.

For instance, imagine you have a commercial facility with limited ceiling clearance. In such a scenario, a rolling steel overhead door would be more convenient as it can be installed directly against the wall or under the ceiling without needing additional tracks or space for the panels to move. This streamlined design ensures that every inch of space is utilised efficiently.

On the other hand, sectional overhead doors operate by moving horizontally along tracks and are composed of several panels hinged together. These doors offer great flexibility as they can be customised to fit different sizes and shapes of door openings. They are particularly ideal for residential garages where ease of access is important.

Let’s say you have a residential garage with ample headroom. In this case, a sectional overhead door could be more convenient as it allows for easy manual operation without the need for complex hardware or motorised systems. The panels slide smoothly along vertical tracks, making it effortless to open and close the door when needed.

Ultimately, choosing between a rolling steel overhead door and a sectional overhead door comes down to evaluating your specific needs and preferences. It’s important to consider elements such as available space, desired level of customization, and ease of operation.

Now that we have explored the convenience and ease of use aspect, let’s turn our attention to another important factor when comparing these two types of doors: evaluating energy efficiency.

Evaluating Energy Efficiency

Energy efficiency is a significant concern for both residential and commercial properties. Choosing a garage door that helps maintain indoor temperatures and reduce energy consumption can make a noticeable difference in utility costs and overall comfort.

Rolling steel overhead doors offer excellent insulation properties with their interlocking slats. These slats provide a tight seal when closed, minimising air leakage and preventing drafts from entering the space. Additionally, some rolling steel doors come with insulation options that enhance their energy efficiency even further by reducing heat transfer.

Picture having a workshop or warehouse where temperature control is crucial to protect sensitive materials or equipment. In such cases, a rolling steel overhead door with insulation features becomes an optimal choice. It ensures that the interior remains well-insulated, keeping the temperature stable and reducing the strain on heating or cooling systems.

Sectional overhead doors can also be energy-efficient depending on their construction materials and insulation options. These doors are available in various materials, such as steel, aluminium, or wood, each with its own insulating properties. By selecting a well-insulated sectional door with weather stripping around its perimeter, you can effectively reduce energy loss through air leakage and improve overall energy efficiency.

Energy efficiency is just one aspect to consider when evaluating different types of garage doors. Let’s now move on to another critical factor: security features and weatherproofing showdown.

Security Features and Weatherproofing Showdown

When it comes to selecting the best type of overhead door for your commercial or industrial space, security features and weatherproofing play a critical role. Both rolling steel overhead doors and sectional overhead doors offer unique advantages that cater to different needs and scenarios.

Rolling steel overhead doors are known for their robustness and enhanced security features. These doors are constructed with durable materials such as steel or aluminium, making them highly resistant to forced entry. The interlocking slat design adds an additional layer of security, preventing unauthorised access to your facility. This makes rolling steel doors an excellent choice for businesses that require high-level security, such as warehouses or storage facilities storing valuable goods.

On the other hand, sectional overhead doors also provide reliable security measures. These doors consist of multiple panels that can be operated individually, allowing for partial opening or closing. The sturdy construction of sectional doors, usually made from steel or aluminium, provides effective protection against intruders. Additionally, advanced locking mechanisms and reinforced hinges further enhance the security aspect of sectional overhead doors.

Picture a warehouse where expensive equipment is stored overnight. In this scenario, both rolling steel and sectional overhead doors would provide adequate security measures. However, if there are concerns about potential break-ins or vandalism due to the nature of the stored items, a rolling steel overhead door might provide an extra sense of protection.

Moving on to weatherproofing capabilities, rolling steel overhead doors often excel in this area as well. These doors are designed to seal tightly and are typically equipped with weather-resistant features such as rubber seals and bottom curtains to prevent drafts, dust, and water infiltration. They can also withstand extreme weather conditions like strong winds or heavy rainfall.

Consider a manufacturing facility located in an area prone to severe weather events such as hurricanes or blizzards. In this case, a rolling steel overhead door would be a suitable choice, as its ability to withstand harsh elements ensures the production area remains insulated and secure.

Sectional overhead doors, too, offer excellent weatherproofing capabilities. The panels of these doors are often designed with insulation materials, providing energy efficiency and protection against temperature fluctuations. Additionally, weather seals and thermal breaks help create a barrier against external conditions, such as rain, wind, or extreme temperatures.

Regardless of whether you choose a rolling steel or sectional overhead door for your commercial or industrial space, it is crucial to consider the specific security needs and weather conditions that the door will be exposed to. This will ensure that you make an informed decision that aligns with your business requirements.

In summary, both rolling steel overhead doors and sectional overhead doors provide reliable security features and impressive weatherproofing capabilities. The choice between the two ultimately depends on factors such as the level of security required and the prevalent weather conditions in your area. Consulting with a professional at Canadoor Garage Doors can help you assess your needs and select the suitable overhead door that guarantees peace of mind and optimal functionality for your business.